· 11 items
City Council, Wednesday, November 4
On the episode: Council approves Riverview Marketplace land use; Gonzales says he's headed to the Assembly
This episode was produced with AI from the public recordings of the week's meetings. Links to the sources are in the show notes.
What happened
City Council Wednesday, November 4
11 items
The recording · Agenda: City Council Meeting 515 · Agenda: City Council Meeting 330 · Post Agenda: City Council Meeting 515 · Post Agenda: City Council Meeting 330
Afternoon public statements (non-agenda) Item 2a
Ethics and meeting rules
Open public comment at the 3:30 p.m. session on matters not on the agenda. One person spoke, about meeting cancellations and how far ahead agendas are posted. 00:21:37
Ward 6 alternate appointment to the Youth Commission Item 3a
Appointments and leadershipYouth
The council filled the Ward 6 alternate seat on the city's Youth Commission for the 2026-27 school year. Appointments are made by ward, so the Ward 6 councilmember makes the nomination. 00:24:19
- Motion to appoint the nominee of Zack Bashirtash (Councilmember, Ward 6) as Ward 6 alternate member of the Youth Commission. Result: passed. 00:25:02
- A councilmember nominated a student applicant as the Ward 6 alternate youth commissioner. 00:24:41
Closed session: two federal lawsuits against the city Item 5a
Lawsuits and settlements
The council met privately with its lawyers about two federal lawsuits now pending against the city in the Eastern District of California; one also names the police department and an officer. Under state law, existing litigation can be discussed in closed session. 00:25:11
- Closed-session direction to the city attorney in both existing-litigation matters. Result: passed, 4-0. 01:04:06
Teen Government Day students introduced Item 1a
The council welcomed high school students taking part in Teen Government Day. They spent the day with city departments, and each one introduced themselves in the role of an elected official or a city department head. 02:02:47
Evening public statements (non-agenda), including a street-repair request Item 5a
Streets and public worksParks and trees
Open public comment at the 5:15 p.m. session. Two people spoke. One asked for time at a future meeting to present a volunteer survey of trees in city parks. The other asked for street repairs in a neighborhood that has no sidewalks, and a councilmember responded. 02:24:26
- A councilmember said the city has been working systematically through the Oleander Sunset area and believes the speaker's section, the last one left, is on the schedule. 02:27:20
- A councilmember promised a personal follow-up with the resident about the repair schedule, noting a decade of work in the area. 02:27:20
Consent calendar, including $14.07 million in Homekey+ housing funds Item 6
HomelessnessFederal and state fundingAffordable housing
Routine items approved together in one vote. They include appropriating $14,074,000 (agenda) in state Homekey+ grant funds and an agreement with Community Action Partnership of Kern for the Ramkabir permanent supportive housing project at 901 Union Avenue. Also included: adoption of the Austin Creek Park zone change, a Dell storage purchase of up to $500,000, a median improvement contract worth $1,025,000, and agreements for an environmental impact report on a future general plan amendment and zone change. A staff memo clarified that item 6c1 had its first reading on October 21, 2026, and transmitted the signed agreement for item 6f1. 02:34:48
- Manpreet Kaur (Councilmember, Ward 7; Vice Mayor) moved to approve consent calendar items 6a through 6j. Result: passed. 02:35:33
Application for the state Prohousing Designation Program Item 7a
Housing supplyAffordable housing
A resolution authorizing the city to apply to the California Department of Housing and Community Development's Prohousing Designation Program and take part in it. The hearing was taken on the consent hearing calendar, and nobody asked to have it pulled for separate discussion. 02:35:50
- Manpreet Kaur (Councilmember, Ward 7; Vice Mayor) moved to adopt consent calendar hearing item 7a. Result: passed. 02:38:53
Riverview Marketplace: old PG&E site at Rosedale Highway and Coffee Road Item 7b
Development projectsZoning and plansPollution
Coffee Road Ventures, LLC asked the council to change the general plan land use designation on about 46.16 acres at the southwest corner of Rosedale Highway and Coffee Road from Public Facilities to Light Industrial. It also asked the council to certify the final environmental impact report (EIR), including a statement of overriding considerations and a mitigation monitoring program. Staff described the site as a former PG&E site; the EIR analyzed a conceptual Riverview Marketplace site plan. According to staff, the EIR found greenhouse gas emissions and vehicle miles traveled to be significant and unavoidable, which requires the statement of overriding considerations. The Planning Commission and staff recommended approval. The item was pulled from the consent hearing calendar because a speaker card was filed in opposition, so it got a full public hearing. 02:39:01
- Bob Smith (Councilmember, Ward 4) moved to support the staff recommendation on item 7b: certify the final EIR with the CEQA findings, statement of overriding considerations and mitigation monitoring program, and adopt the general plan amendment from Public Facilities to Light Industrial. Result: passed. 03:13:28
- City staff presented the request for the land use change on the 46.16-acre site at 2401 Coffee Road. 02:39:21
- City staff reported that the EIR found significant unavoidable impacts from greenhouse gas emissions and vehicle miles traveled. Impacts on air quality, biological, cultural and geological resources were found to be mitigated. 02:41:30
- City staff listed the project's benefits as jobs, revenue and redevelopment of an unused former PG&E site. 02:41:30
- The city manager described the site as an old industrial property and the project as a notable redevelopment whose mitigations have already been planned for. 02:42:20
- The city manager said staff recommends approving the land use designation. 02:42:20
- A consultant for the city said, as the preparer of the EIR for the city, that the final EIR discusses dust suppression measures that would limit the spread of valley fever spores. 02:51:56
- A consultant for the city said the project must prepare an air district dust control plan, which would include watering and real-time perimeter dust monitoring during earthwork. 02:53:01
- A consultant for the city listed real-time perimeter dust monitoring and covered haul loads among the measures in the dust control plan. 02:54:03
- Bob Smith (Councilmember, Ward 4) called it a great project, said he believed the EIR looked at everything, and said he looks forward to the economic development. 03:08:07
- City staff advised that a single motion supporting the staff recommendation would cover both resolutions. 03:08:29
- A councilmember cited the jobs and sales figures presented at the hearing, along with the reported effect of a Whole Foods on nearby property values. 03:08:41
- A councilmember acknowledged the dust concerns but said they will be addressed, and called the project better for the area than a vacant lot. 03:09:42
- A councilmember recalled that the site once held an idle, diesel-burning power plant that has since been removed. 03:11:00
- A councilmember said the site has gone through extensive state-supervised cleanup and carries restrictions that bar housing, hotels or any habitation. 03:12:01
- A councilmember called the EIR thorough, noting that outside counsel worked on it and that several developers have taken the project through the process. 03:12:01
- The presiding officer recalled the community's excitement when Whole Foods was announced more than two years ago. 03:13:05
Bid for 15-gallon and 24-inch box trees Item 10a
Parks and treesClimate and sustainability
The council was asked to accept a bid from Zack's Big Trees & Nursery for 15-gallon and 24-inch box trees for the Recreation and Parks Department, in the amount of $274,413.75 (agenda; also read by the clerk). Staff said the bid sets unit prices and does not commit the city to spending that amount. They presented a plan for the $500,000 the council previously set aside for trees, covering contracted plantings, plantings by city staff, schools, community groups and a tree voucher program, with most planting targeted at hotter, low-canopy, disadvantaged areas. The item was deferred from an earlier meeting. 03:13:38
- A councilmember moved to accept the bid from Zack's Big Trees & Nursery for $274,413.75 (agenda). Result: passed. Abstained: Andrae Gonzales (Councilmember, Ward 2). 03:43:12
- A councilmember said he would recuse himself from item 10a because he received a campaign contribution related to the matter. 03:14:06
- City staff stressed that the item is a bid award, not an obligation to spend the money. 03:27:00
- The city manager described the item as a competitive low-bid purchase that fits within a larger plan the city will shape with feedback from the community, the Tree Advisory Group and the council. 03:27:57
- The city manager said the city wants to get as many trees planted as possible within a narrow time window. 03:29:04
- City staff said the largest share, about $200,000, would go to contracted plantings by Kern Sprinkler, which already holds a city contract, mostly on streetscapes. 03:29:18
- City staff said $100,000 would go to plantings by city staff at infill sites and parks. 03:30:20
- City staff said about $50,000 would go to tree donations to schools. Bakersfield City School District has been contacted, and staff were directed to reach out to Greenfield and Panama-Buena Vista. 03:30:20
- City staff said $100,000 would go to community organizations able to plant, irrigate and maintain large plantings. 03:30:20
- City staff said the last $50,000 would fund a tree voucher program for residents, with a workshop on planting and care. 03:31:21
- City staff noted the department has another $75,000 in its budget that could add to any of the categories, and that money can shift between them depending on response. 03:31:21
- City staff said that, according to a memo from the recreation and parks director, at least 80 percent of the trees will go to the mapped focus area of hotter, low-canopy, disadvantaged neighborhoods. 03:32:23
- Bob Smith (Councilmember, Ward 4) asked how the roughly $274,000 bid fits into the $500,000 plan. 03:33:42
- City staff explained that the bid only identified the lowest-priced nursery against a set tree list, and that the city can spend less or more with it. 03:33:50
- The city manager said the city would buy trees in volume and give them to volunteer groups to plant, so not every dollar is tied yet to a specific category. 03:35:02
- City staff said the bid amount is not tied to the tree plan; the plan covers the overall $500,000 in spending. 03:37:47
- The city manager said the action mainly sets prices, and that some money could go to a separate contract for purchase and planting. 03:38:36
- A councilmember said the trees need to be bought to get started, and that the plan is not final and can be adjusted. 03:38:54
- City staff said the recreation and parks director will vet planting locations for adequate irrigation and maintenance capacity. 03:40:01
- A councilmember asked whether the city would take responsibility for building infrastructure where trees have never been planted before. 03:40:48
- City staff said building irrigation infrastructure is a significant investment and could come to the council as separate projects. 03:41:16
- The city manager said that if plantings continue next year, staff would recommend setting aside money for irrigation infrastructure as well as for trees. 03:41:42
2027 council meeting and budget calendar Item 11a
A resolution setting the dates of 2027 regular council meetings, department budget presentations and the budget hearing. Staff said it follows recent years' pattern of two meetings a month, with longer gaps in July and September. 03:43:28
- Manpreet Kaur (Councilmember, Ward 7; Vice Mayor) moved to adopt the resolution setting the 2027 meeting and budget calendar. Result: passed. 03:45:12
Council statements: Ward 2 councilmember elected to the State Assembly Item 12
Elections and ballot measures
During council statements, the Ward 2 councilmember announced he had been elected to the State Assembly the night before and will leave the council. His last meeting is November 18, which opens the Ward 2 seat. 03:45:22
▶ Hear it A councilmember's Assembly win opens a seat on the council · 0:56
- A councilmember announced that voters in Assembly District 35 elected him to the State Assembly the previous night. 03:45:31
- A councilmember said he will take the oath of office in Sacramento on December 7. 03:45:31
- A councilmember said he will leave the Ward 2 seat he has held for ten years, and that the November 18 meeting will be his last. 03:45:31
Public comment
- Afternoon session, non-agenda (1 speaker): A resident complained that city meetings and committee meetings are often cancelled and that councilmembers miss committee meetings. They also criticized past agenda packets of 2,000 to 5,000 pages posted 48 hours ahead, but thanked the clerk and staff for posting this week's agendas the previous Thursday. They urged posting full agendas and EIRs at least a week ahead.
- Evening session, non-agenda (2 speakers): A CSUB professor who sits on the city's Tree Advisory Group said they and five students have surveyed trees in 12 city parks without pay, and asked for ten minutes at the November 18 meeting to present the results. A resident of Winnebago Street said recent pothole repairs in a neighborhood without sidewalks have not held up, putting elderly walkers and parents with strollers at risk, and asked the city to review the roads.
- Evening session, agenda items (1 speaker, on item 10a): A Sierra Club representative asked where the plan is for the full $500,000 approved for trees on June 24, 2026, and where the maintenance plan is for existing trees, many of which they said are dying. They said tree trimming happens in September even though national standards call for November, and that tree advocates and the Tree Advisory Group were left out of the RFP. They cited a November 3 letter to the Fair Political Practices Commission and the state Attorney General raising lobbying and conflict-of-interest concerns, and asked for monthly reports on tree trimming, removal, planting and costs.
- Item 7b hearing, opposition (1 speaker plus rebuttal): A representative of CARE California, a nonprofit representing workers, asked the council not to approve the project. They said disturbing 46 acres next to a senior community creates a high valley fever risk, and that none of the measures their expert proposed were adopted: watering the site three to four times a day, N95 respirators for workers, and construction equipment with enclosed cabs. They called for a revised and recirculated EIR. In rebuttal, they argued that Cal/OSHA rules protect workers, not nearby residents, and that no evidence shows the proposed measures are infeasible.
- Item 7b hearing, support (4 registered speakers plus rebuttals): The applicant's legal counsel argued that recirculating the EIR is not legally required because no significant new information was added, and that the added biological mitigation responded to the California Department of Fish and Wildlife. The counsel also said the measures opponents proposed are infeasible. A representative of the developer, Coffee Road Ventures, said the project would bring over $100 million in private investment and Bakersfield's first Whole Foods, with a signed lease. They also projected about 2,000 jobs (about 1,250 permanent), about $2 million in sales tax revenue for the city, and about $1 million in property tax to the county. The president of the Kern Economic Development Corporation cited the draw of a Whole Foods and its reported effect on nearby property values. In rebuttal, one young resident called the former PG&E plant an eyesore and backed the project for its jobs, while asking that elderly neighbors be protected.
What's next
- Andrae Gonzales (Councilmember, Ward 2) said November 18 will be his last council meeting and that he takes the Assembly oath in Sacramento on December 7, which leaves the Ward 2 seat open.
- A CSUB professor asked for ten minutes at the November 18 meeting to present a volunteer survey of trees in city parks. No commitment was made on the record.
- A councilmember promised to follow up personally with a resident about the street repair schedule in the Oleander Sunset area.
- Tree plan: staff said irrigation infrastructure for new planting sites could come to the council as separate projects, and that if planting continues next year staff would recommend setting aside irrigation money as well as tree money.
- The council approved agreements to fund and prepare an EIR for General Plan Amendment/Zone Change No. 24-0514 and Williamson Act Cancelation No. 26-0001 (consent item 6f3).